• Follow us

Technology

Facebook found hosting masses of far right EU disinformation networks – TechCrunch

A multi-month hunt for political disinformation spreading on Facebook in Europe suggests there are concerted efforts to use the platform to spread bogus far right propaganda to millions of voters ahead of a key EU vote which kicks off tomorrow.

Following the independent investigation, Facebook has taken down a total of 77 pages and 230 accounts from Germany, UK, France, Italy, Spain and Poland — which had been followed by an estimated 32 million people and generated 67 million ‘interactions’ (i.e. comments, likes, shares) in the last three months alone.

The bogus mainly far-right disinformation networks were not identified by Facebook — but had been reported to it by campaign group Avaaz — which says the fake pages had more Facebook followers and interactions than all the main EU far right and anti-EU parties combined.

“The results are overwhelming: the disinformation networks upon which Facebook acted had more interactions (13 million) in the past three months than the main party pages of the League, AfD, VOX, Brexit Party, Rassemblement National and PiS combined (9 million),” it writes in a new report.

“Although interactions is the figure that best illustrates the impact and reach of these networks, comparing the number of followers of the networks taken down reveals an even clearer image. The Facebook networks takedown had almost three times (5.9 million) the number of followers as AfD, VOX, Brexit Party, Rassemblement National and PiS’s main Facebook pages combined (2 million).”

Avaaz has previously found and announced far right disinformation networks operating in Spain, Italy and Poland — and a spokesman confirmed to us it’s re-reporting some of its findings now (such as the ~30 pages and groups in Spain that had racked up 1.7M followers and 7.4M interactions, which we covered last month) to highlight an overall total for the investigation.

“Our report contains new information for France, United Kingdom and Germany,” the spokesman added.

Examples of politically charged disinformation being spread via Facebook by the bogus networks it found include a fake viral video seen by 10 million people that supposedly shows migrants in Italy destroying a police car (but was actually from a movie; which Avaaz adds that this fake had been “debunked years ago”); a story in Poland claiming that migrant taxi drivers rape European women, including a fake image; and fake news about a child cancer center being closed down by Catalan separatists in Spain.

There’s lots more country-specific detail in its full report.

In all, Avaaz reported more than 500 suspicious pages and groups to Facebook related to the three-month investigation of Facebook disinformation networks in Europe. Though Facebook only took down a subset of the far right muck-spreaders — around 15% of the suspicious pages reported to it.

“The networks were either spreading disinformation or using tactics to amplify their mainly anti-immigration, anti-EU, or racist content, in a way that appears to breach Facebook’s own policies,” Avaaz writes of what it found.

It estimates that content posted by all the suspicious pages it reported had been viewed some 533 million times over the pre-election period. Albeit, there’s no way to know whether or not everything it judged suspicious actually was.

In a statement responding to Avaaz’s findings, Facebook told us:

We thank Avaaz for sharing their research for us to investigate. As we have said, we are focused on protecting the integrity of elections across the European Union and around the world. We have removed a number of fake and duplicate accounts that were violating our authenticity policies, as well as multiple Pages for name change and other violations. We also took action against some additional Pages that repeatedly posted misinformation. We will take further action if we find additional violations.

The company did not respond to our question asking why it failed to unearth this political disinformation itself.

Ahead of the EU parliament vote, which begins tomorrow, Facebook invited a select group of journalists to tour a new Dublin-based election security ‘war room’ — where it talked about a “five pillars of countering disinformation” strategy to prevent cynical attempts to manipulate voters’ views.

But as Avaaz’s investigation shows there’s plenty of political disinformation flying by entirely unchecked.

One major ongoing issue where political disinformation and Facebook’s platform is concerned is that how the company enforces its own rules remains entirely opaque.

We don’t get to see all the detail — so can’t judge and assess all its decisions. Yet Facebook has been known to shut down swathes of accounts deemed fake ahead of elections, while apparently failing entirely to find other fakes (such as in this case).

It’s a situation that does not look compatible with the continued functioning of democracy given Facebook’s massive reach and power to influence.

Nor is the company under an obligation to report every fake account it confirms. Instead, Facebook gets to control the timing and flow of any official announcements it chooses to make about “coordinated inauthentic behaviour” — dropping these self-selected disclosures as and when it sees fit, and making them sound as routine as possible by cloaking them in its standard, dryly worded newspeak.

Back in January, Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg admitted publicly that the company is blocking more than 1M fake accounts every day. If Facebook was reporting every fake it finds it would therefore need to do so via a real-time dashboard — not sporadic newsroom blog posts that inherently play down the scale of what is clearly embedded into its platform, and may be so massive and ongoing that it’s not really possible to know where Facebook stops and ‘Fakebook’ starts.

The suspicious behaviours that Avaaz attached to the pages and groups it found that appeared to be in breach of Facebook’s stated rules include the use of fake accounts, spamming, misleading page name changes and suspected coordinated inauthentic behavior.

When Avaaz previously reported the Spanish far right networks Facebook subsequently told us it had removed “a number” of pages violating its “authenticity policies”, including one page for name change violations but claimed “we aren’t removing accounts or Pages for coordinated inauthentic behavior”.

So again, it’s worth emphasizing that Facebook gets to define what is and isn’t acceptable on its platform — including creating terms that seek to normalize its own inherently dysfunctional ‘rules’ and their ‘enforcement’.

Such as by creating terms like “coordinated inauthentic behavior”, which sets a threshold of Facebook’s own choosing for what it will and won’t judge political disinformation. It’s inherently self-serving.

Given that Facebook only acted on a small proportion of what Avaaz found and reported overall, we might posit that the company is setting a very high bar for acting against suspicious activity. And that plenty of election fiddling is free flowing under its feeble radar. (When we previously asked Facebook whether it was disputing Avaaz’s finding of coordinated inauthentic behaviour vis-a-vis the far right disinformation networks it reported in Spain the company did not respond to the question.)

Much of the publicity around Facebook’s self-styled “election security” efforts has also focused on how it’s enforcing new disclosure rules around political ads. But again political disinformation masquerading as organic content continues being spread across its platform — where it’s being shown to be racking up millions of interactions with people’s brains and eyeballs.

Plus, as we reported yesterday, research conducted by the Oxford Internet Institute into pre-EU election content sharing on Facebook has found that sources of disinformation-spreading ‘junk news’ generate far greater engagement on its platform than professional journalism.

So while Facebook’s platform is also clearly full of real people sharing actual news and views, the fake BS which Avaaz’s findings imply is also flooding the platform, gets spread around more, on a per unit basis. And it’s democracy that suffers — because vote manipulators are able to pass off manipulative propaganda and hate speech as bona fide news and views as a consequence of Facebook publishing the fake stuff alongside genuine opinions and professional journalism.

It does not have algorithms that can perfectly distinguish one from the other, and has suggested it never will.

The bottom line is that even if Facebook dedicates far more resource (human and AI) to rooting out ‘election interference’ the wider problem is that a commercial entity which benefits from engagement on an ad-funded platform is also the referee setting the rules.

Indeed, the whole loud Facebook publicity effort around “election security” looks like a cynical attempt to distract the rest of us from how broken its rules are. Or, in other words, a platform that accelerates propaganda is also seeking to manipulate and skew our views.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechNewsWorld

Dodging Facebook's 'Like' Trap for Small Businesses 2019-06-07 08:00:00Despite complaints about user privacy and the sharing of personal data, Facebook remains the de facto social media powerhouse. It may have started out

Big Data: The Key Focus of a Data 2019-06-06 19:52:58Big data -- a term used with increasing frequency -- refers to the rafts of data that businesses collect on a day-to-day basis, both advertently and i

MX Linux Reinvents Computer Use 2019-06-06 14:36:13MX Linux is a blend of mostly old and some new things, resulting in an appealing midweight Linux OS. The midweight category is a bit unusual. Desktop

Reliving D-Day Through Augmented Reality 2019-06-06 11:23:54The National Museum of the US Air Force in Dayton, Ohio, is honoring the exploits and sacrifices of the Greatest Generation in a new augmented reality

YouTube Punishes Homophobic, Racist Pundit Following Internet Furor 2019-06-06 06:10:41YouTube on Wednesday demonetized the account of right-wing commentator Steven Crowder following widespread indignation over its initial response to hi

Apple Highlights User Experience in New OS Lineup 2019-06-05 06:11:05Apple dangled the next versions of iOS, macOS and watchOS before developers' eyes during the keynote event at its World Wide Developers Conference in

Apple Spotlights Privacy, Big Iron at WWDC 2019-06-04 13:11:15Privacy, a new muscular Mac Pro workstation, and the debut of iPadOS were topline items at Apple's WWDC keynote. During its more than two-hour presen

AMD Slam-Dunks Intel at Computex and It's a 2019-06-03 13:23:30Like a lot of folks, I'm a tad sick of Intel. Last month we learned of its second big security scandal in as many years. Once again, the company not

Leveraging Live Video Streaming, the Great Democratizer 2019-06-01 08:00:00When live streaming first started to roll out across multiple social media platforms, it remained pretty unclear how this new technology would interfa

Amazon Debuts Echo Show 5: Smaller, Cheaper, More 2019-05-30 12:22:59Amazon has announced the Echo Show 5 and is taking preorders. This third-generation Echo Show is called the "5" because it has a 5.5-inch diagonal d

GitHub Opens New Door to Financial Support for 2019-05-29 13:29:26GitHub has made it easier for open source developers to garner financial support as recipients of paid sponsorships. GitHub Sponsors, launched in beta

Apple's New iPod Gets in Touch With Gamers 2019-05-29 05:35:19Apple has refreshed its iPod touch line of media players with a faster processor, greater storage capacity and improved communications features. The n

PCWorld

Newegg is selling the ray tracing-ready Zotac RTX 2019-06-17 09:57:00If you're looking for a new graphics card, you'll want to check out this Newegg deal today: The Zotac Gaming GeForce RTX 2080 is on sale for $6

HP Chromebook x360 14 G1 review: A giant, 2019-06-17 06:30:00The HP Chromebook x360 14 G1 is HP’s latest attempt to create the ultimate premium Chromebook. Aimed at corporate users who want something nicer

How to check your graphics card's GPU temperature 2019-06-17 06:03:00How hot is your PC’s graphics card temperature? During normal operations, your GPU temperature shouldn’t matter much—your graphics c

TVision by T-Mobile review: This streaming TV service 2019-06-17 06:00:00If you don’t like making sacrifices in your TV entertainment choices, and it’s available where you live, TVision isn’t a bad deal. B

41 must-see PC games at E3 2019: Watch 2019-06-14 14:36:00E3 2019 is probably the most PC-centric show we’ve seen in years, what with Microsoft announcing Xbox Game Pass for PC and bringing its future f

Huawei delays the launch of its $2,600 folding 2019-06-14 14:11:00Following the near-disastrous roll-out of the Galaxy Fold, Huawei has delayed the launch of the Mate X folding phone, which was due to arrive this mon

Best antivirus for Mac: Protect yourself from malicious 2019-06-14 14:05:00We name the top free and paid Mac antivirus products to root out malicious software and prevent infections.

Blue's high-fidelity foldable microphone for laptops and Macbooks 2019-06-14 11:39:00Most of us probably know Blue microphones for their longtime podcasting and gaming favorite, the Blue Yeti. But the brand has plenty of other options

The Full Nerd ep. 96: 16-core Ryzen, Radeon 2019-06-14 10:45:00In this episode of The Full Nerd, Gordon Mah Ung, Brad Chacos, Alaina Yee, and Adam Patrick Murray dig into AMD’s major

Get 200+ hours of CompTIA certification training for 2019-06-14 10:05:00A myriad of jobs will be eliminated in the coming years. Will automation threaten yours? Ensure your livelihood — and save thousands at the same

The blazing-fast 500GB Samsung 970 Evo SSD is 2019-06-14 09:43:00If you have an empty M.2 NVMe slot in your desktop or laptop, now’s the time to put it to good use with an ultra-fast SSD. Amazon is selling the

Move data from your PC to iOS with 2019-06-14 09:05:00iOS users know the anguish associated with upgrading to a new device, largely due to the massive hassle that is moving data between devices. Thankfull

FOX News

Google wants next billion users, but has no 2019-06-17 11:09:24Google CEO Sundar Pichai said his company doesn't have plans to launch in China, but that doesn't mean the tech giant wants to ignore its hundreds o

Amazon slams AOC claim for saying it pays 2019-06-17 10:06:59Amazon on Monday fired back at Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y. after she claimed that the tech giant pays its warehouse workers "starvation wag

Buttigieg fears tech could fuel racially biased credit 2019-06-17 09:33:13Pete Buttigieg fears that artificial intelligence may further fuel racial bias in America's already challenging credit scoring system.

Russia used social media to influence EU citizens' 2019-06-17 09:04:00A report from the European Commission on disinformation has said that Russian sources attempted to influence the recent European elections through soc

Pentagon seeks laser-armed space drones to attack enemy 2019-06-17 08:14:45Laser-armed drones operating in space may soon sense, track, target and ultimately incinerate enemy Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles flying above t

$4 AirPods, robocalls ending, delete car data, and 2019-06-16 06:00:38End annoying robocalls, delete car data and get some real talk on cord-cutting.

20 everyday tasks that nobody does anymore 2019-06-15 06:00:44Daily necessities are vanishing one by one, thanks to new and efficient technology.

7 cool gadgets for summer fun 2019-06-14 16:49:07Summer is already in full force, and that means it’s time to head out to the beach, take a long bike ride, or explore the great outdoors. These

Does Amazon really pay no taxes? Here’s the 2019-06-14 13:21:28Democratic presidential candidates have seized on reports that Amazon.com Inc. paid no 2018 federal taxes as they press for changes in

Pressure mounts on Facebook over Mark Zuckerberg's emails 2019-06-14 12:46:22Facebook's privacy policies — and how its CEO Mark Zuckerberg allegedly discussed them internally — are under a microscope.

5G speeds, online prescriptions, creepy car cameras, and 2019-06-09 06:00:08Answering all of your questions about 5G speeds, online prescriptions, those creepy car cameras and much more.

5 ways to protect your child online 2019-06-08 06:00:33The truth is, the internet was never really designed for children. Yes, it’s exciting to connect everyone in the world, to celebrate freedom of

TechCrunch

This $99 AirPower knockoff is available for order 2019-06-18 17:04:50There are a number of key differences between Apple’s AirPower and lookalike knockoff, AirUnleashed. The most pertinent one, however, is that on

An open letter to Google and Apple: Stop 2019-06-18 17:00:43Take away my toolbox and ask me to be a carpenter. This is what Google and Apple are asking of Iran’s budding entrepreneurship sector by barring

Atlassian’s co-CEO Scott Farquhar will join us at 2019-06-18 16:39:36Few companies have changed the way developers work as profoundly as Atlassian. Its tools like Jira and Confluence are ubiquitous and over the course o

Careteam aims to unite patients and healthcare providers 2019-06-18 16:35:30How best to untangle the Gordian knot that is navigating your own healthcare? It’s a tricky question, and one that seems to have become only mor

For pen testing firm IOActive, security is cultural 2019-06-18 16:26:18IOActive may not be a household name but you almost certainly know its work. The Seattle-headquartered company has been behind some of the most breath

Probably Genetic helps families identify genetic conditions early 2019-06-18 16:22:49Probably Genetic hopes to provide families of children on the autism spectrum with more complete diagnoses.

Tesla is turning its showrooms into arcades 2019-06-18 16:19:09Tesla might not engage in traditional advertising. That doesn’t mean the automaker isn’t keen on getting new customers and retaining the o

VidAngel ordered to pay $62.4M for copyright infringement 2019-06-18 14:53:27The VidAngel story seemingly ended in late 2017 when it declared Chapter 11 bankruptcy. But the bad news wasn’t over for the streaming service,

YouTube’s new AR Beauty Try-On lets viewers virtually 2019-06-18 14:41:14Makeup tutorials and reviews are some of the most popular content on YouTube, as they help people learn about new products as well as how to apply the

Fresh off a $2.65B valuation, Plaid co-founder William 2019-06-18 14:28:56"This conclusion was neither a rash nor a recent decision," Hockey explains.

Cruise is sharing its data visualization tool with 2019-06-18 14:28:22Cruise is sharing a software platform with roboticists that was initially created to give its own engineers a better understanding of the petabytes of

SafeAI raises $5M to develop and deploy autonomy 2019-06-18 14:27:38Startup SafeAI, powered by a founding talent team with experience across Apple, Ford and Caterpillar, is emerging from stealth today with a $5 million

Electrek

Another setback for utility-regulated EV charging, we need 2019-06-18 16:36:57 Kentucky is now the latest state to find that Electric Vehicle Charging Stations (EVCSs) are exempt from utility regulation. Had Kentucky’s Pub

Tesla’s biggest bear Jim Chanos becomes biggest hypocrite 2019-06-18 16:30:24 Tesla has many detractors but maybe none bigger than hedge fund manager Jim Chanos who has consistently compared Tesla to a fraud and said that its C

US solar market sees strongest Q1 ever, industry 2019-06-18 14:45:57 The US installed 2.7 gigawatts of solar photovoltaics in the first quarter of 2019, marking the country’s strongest installation numbers ever i

Bosch unveils new 2020 e-bike motors and batteries, 2019-06-18 14:33:54 Bosch’s electric bicycle motors and batteries have been leading the market for years without seeing many significant advancements. Now the comp

Tesla launches new ‘Arcade’ app, produces funny commercial 2019-06-18 14:32:02 After first teasing it at E3 last week, Tesla is now launching its new ‘Arcade’ app and it produced a funny commercial for its new in-car

Anker’s Powerhouse 120000mAh Portable Generator is $350 (Reg. 2019-06-18 13:33:07 Anker’s eBay storefront offers its Powerhouse 400Wh 120000mAh Portable Generator for $349.99 shipped. Discount reflected in-cart.  Re

EVgo announces roaming agreements with ChargePoint, EV Connect 2019-06-18 13:07:35 Charging network EVgo announced today that it has reached roaming agreements with ChargePoint and EV Connect, making it easier for EVgo users to char

Ireland’s climate plan calls for ICE ban, 950,000 2019-06-18 11:48:17 Ireland has released an ambitious new Climate Action Plan that aims to achieve net zero emissions by 2050, with a goal of putting 950,000 electric ve

The first Tesla Pickup truck is here – 2019-06-18 11:00:23 We are all waiting for an imminent announcement about the unveiling of the Tesla pickup truck later this year, but now a YouTuber has beaten the auto

Eviation’s all-electric Alice airplane coming to US regional 2019-06-18 10:27:11 All-electric aircraft manufacturer Eviation Aircraft has announced its first commercial customer — Cape Air, a Massachusetts-based regiona

Revolt unveils 125cc class electric motorcycle with nearly 2019-06-18 10:24:17 India has set some of the most aggressive two-wheeled electric vehicle adoption legislation in the world. Combined with the country’s high rate

Porsche CEO gives props to Tesla, says EVs 2019-06-18 09:41:29 Porsche has been making a 180-degree turn on all-electric vehicles in recent years. They are now giving props to Tesla and saying that electric vehic

Ars Technica UK

Experts say they were duped into appearing in 2019-06-18 17:03:06"You have placed my interview among those of people who are charlatans and thieves."

iOS 13 will remind you to cancel your 2019-06-18 16:48:36The feature is included in the latest beta release of iOS 13.

People keep spotting Teslas with snoozing drivers on 2019-06-18 16:34:10Hundreds die in non-Tesla drowsy-driving crashes every year.

Samsung asks users to please virus-scan their TVs 2019-06-18 16:16:50Samsung Support USA deleted its own virus-scanning recommendation.

New vulnerabilities may let hackers remotely SACK Linux 2019-06-18 15:53:05Netflix researchers discovered 4 flaws that could wreak havoc in data centers.

New Zealand judge sends neo-Nazi to prison for 2019-06-18 15:00:46Sharing the video is illegal in NZ and "encourages mass murder," judge says.

Dealmaster: Get a Nintendo Switch Pro Controller for 2019-06-18 13:55:55Plus last call on Nintendo's E3 sale, a Lenovo ThinkPad laptop deal, and more.

Electric car charging interoperability is the next big 2019-06-18 13:20:47More companies sign bilateral agreements, but there's an even better solution out there.

Google’s ninth attempt at a messaging service will 2019-06-18 13:15:21Google's RCS service will launch in the UK and France later this month.

Ars on your lunch break: The fate we 2019-06-18 12:00:08Because it's not a talk about the future if we don't mention Skynet at least once.

In the not-so-distant future, “synbio” could lead to 2019-06-18 12:00:01Come listen to a TED talk and then discuss the darker side of synthetic biology.

Facebook launches cryptocurrency with Visa, MasterCard, Uber, and 2019-06-18 11:54:29Facebook plans to bring payments to Whatsapp and Messenger in 2020.


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.